Heart Rate and Power: A Dual Relationship

Heart rate and power measure different things, and a power meter does not make a heart rate monitor redundant. This post sets out what each one tells you and why a coach tracks both.

Do you still need a heart rate monitor?

Over the last 10 years as power meters have become more readily available and more affordable, more people than ever can have access to this great training tool.
But does having a power meter mean that the trusted heart rate monitor is no longer needed?

The simple answer is NO.

Chart showing heart rate and power for one ride

Heart rate and power: five differences

Below are a few brief points exploring the differences and relationship of both HR & Pwr.

  • Power provides very precise measurements of the AMOUNT of work you are doing in your training. Heart Rate provides the measurement of the body’s RESPONSE to the amount of training being done.
  • Power allows the establishment of a baseline FITNESS which can be improved with training. Heart Rate establishes a baseline HEART RATE which cannot be improved. It is the power that is the quantifiable measure of FITNESS when compared against the baseline HEART RATE.
  • Power allows for very EXACT training zones to be set because ultimately, 1 watt = 1 watt. Heart rate only allows for GENERAL training zones due to the many variables that can affect the body’s RESPONSE to pushing the watts. eg. Fatigue, tiredness, stress, lack of sleep, cardiac drift, or even too much caffeine, etc.
  • Power allows MEASUREMENT of MICRO changes in fitness.
  • Heart rate will give the MEASUREMENT of LARGE changes in fitness.

  • Consistent retesting will lead to increased POWER TRAINING ZONES which ensures progressive overload throughout a training plan, in turn creating greater AMOUNT OF WORK output on the bike. Once the baseline HEART RATE has been established, retesting may only show a change of 1 or 2 bpm but will not show vast changes. Therefore, if consistently training only with heart rate, this means that over time you will feel fitter but not necessarily be getting stronger, as progressive overload to train harder has not been possible due to the lack of INCREASED Power Training Zones.

Conclusion: why a coach tracks both measures

Power is the ‘AMOUNT’ of what you are pushing on the pedals, and Heart Rate is the ‘RESPONSE’ to pushing. But a coach needs to be able to track both measures in training, especially when there are questions such as ‘I could push 240w yesterday no problem and today I struggled to hold 200w’, and heart rate becomes the first point of call to start investigating the answer.

If you’d like help using your training data to guide your sessions, you can read how coaching works at Phases Cycling or get in touch.

Des Martin is the founder and coach at Phases Cycling, based in Girona, Spain. He is an Association of British Cycling Coaches Level 3 coach, a TrainingPeaks Certified Level 2 coach and a qualified sports therapist (VTCT Level 4 Sports Practitioners Diploma).

Related reading: Functional Threshold Power: Is the FTP Test Useful or Too Variable? · Resting Heart Rate: What does it tell us? · Pedal Stroke: Theories, Technique and Training